ISLAMABAD: The revival of the Afghanistan Premier League (APL) has sparked a fierce ethical debate, with critics accusing international cricketers and governing bodies of overlooking the Taliban’s systematic restrictions on women and girls in pursuit of lucrative franchise contracts.
The controversy intensified after three of the 14 English players who entered the APL draft withdrew following public backlash. Players reportedly stand to earn nearly £80,000, raising questions about whether financial incentives justify participation in a competition linked to a cricket board whose chairman is appointed by the Taliban authorities.
🇦🇫AFGHANISTAN PREMIER LEAGUE IN BIG TROUBLE! 🏏
▪️ The PCB has also refused to grant NOCs to Pakistani players for the APL.
▪️ Two other cricket boards have also denied permission to their players to participate.
▪️ The league is set to begin on December 27, but two teams are still waiting to be sold!
– India often talks about brotherhood with Afghanistan, but shouldn’t Indian cricket send its players to the APL to help bring excitement and star power to the league?
INDIA TALKS ABOUT BROTHERHOOD BUT WHERE IS THE SUPPORT WHEN AFGHANISTAN NEEDS IT? 🤔
— Talha Nawaz (@TalhaDigital007) October 14, 2026
Former England captain Rob Key said on a podcast that players faced a moral rather than purely legal decision, stressing that they must be prepared to take the right ethical stance.
Read Also: Taliban Arrest Afghan Women over Dress Code as UN Reports Widespread Abuses
The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has confirmed it will issue No Objection Certificates (NOCs) to eligible players wishing to participate. Critics, however, have questioned the apparent double standard in refusing bilateral cricket series against Afghanistan while permitting players to compete in its franchise league.
🚨 Afghanistan Premier League in trouble! 🇦🇫🏏 PCB, ECB and Cricket Australia (CA) will reportedly issue no NOCs to their players for the league. 😳🔥
#APL #AfghanistanCricket #PakistanCricket #EnglandCricket #CricketNews https://t.co/41CTECN2pX
— Cricket 360 (@RealCrickets360) October 14, 2026
The debate comes against a grim human rights backdrop. Since returning to power in 2021, the Taliban have barred girls from secondary education and imposed sweeping restrictions on women’s freedom, employment and public participation.
Afghanistan’s women cricketers have also been forced into exile amid fears for their safety, highlighting the stark contrast between the men’s team’s international opportunities and the exclusion of women from the sport.
🚨 OLLIE POPE STEPS AWAY FROM THE APL!
– Ollie Pope has withdrawn from the upcoming Afghanistan Premier League draft after widespread backlash over English players’ participation.
– Despite the ECB considering NOCs under UK trade laws, Pope has decided to pull out completely. https://t.co/xIyaOjDzF6
— M Farhan (@MFarhan1200) October 12, 2026
Critics argue that the APL’s revival risks providing the Taliban-controlled system with a valuable public relations platform, presenting Afghanistan as stable enough to host a commercial sporting competition. Although this year’s tournament is planned for the United Arab Emirates, organisers reportedly envisage holding it in Kabul in the future.
Read Also: King Charles Welcomes Afghan Women Cricketers Threatened by Taliban
The financial argument has also drawn scrutiny. Some players, including Moeen Ali, have extensive experience in lucrative franchise competitions worldwide, prompting questions about whether another contract is worth the reputational and ethical costs.
AFGHANISTAN LEAGUE IN TROUBLE.
PCB – No NOCs will be issued.
ECB – No NOCs will be issued.
CA – No NOCs will be issued.Season starts on 27 December, but two teams are still unsold. Wonder why India isn’t stepping in to save its best friend?
— Sheri. (@CallMeSheri1_) October 14, 2026
Opponents of participation warn that overseas stars could help attract commercial interest and revenue to a league operating under authorities that deny women and girls equal access to cricket.
Read Also: Afghan Women Escape Taliban Regime to Play International Football
The controversy has also exposed criticism of the International Cricket Council (ICC), which continues to allow Afghanistan’s men’s team to compete internationally despite the exclusion of women from cricket.
Critics argue that the ICC’s commitment to gender equality demands greater consistency between its stated principles and its treatment of Afghanistan.
Read Also: Human Rights in Grave Danger Under Afghan Taliban: Afghan Activist
Supporters of continued engagement contend that boycotting the men’s team may do little to improve conditions for Afghan women. Critics of the APL, however, distinguish between playing against a national team and participating in a commercial league that could help legitimise the authorities governing the sport.
Read Also: Afghanistan Under Taliban Regime Becomes ‘Epicenter of Terrorism’
Ultimately, the dispute raises a difficult question for international cricket: should players accept lucrative contracts when their participation may help promote a system that systematically denies women and girls basic rights?
